Judge Andrew Napolitano

What if Laws Applied to Everyone?

By Judge Andrew Napolitano - Thursday, June 6, 2013

What if government officials have written laws that apply only to us and not to them? What if we gave them the power to protect our freedoms and our safety and they used that power to trick and trap some of us? What if government officials broke the laws we hired them to enforce? What if they prosecuted others for breaking the same laws they broke?

What if the government enacted a law making it a crime to provide material assistance to terrorist organizations? What if that law was intended to stop people from giving cash and weapons to organizations that bomb and maim and kill? What if the government looked at that law and claimed it applied to a dentist or a shopkeeper who sold services or goods to a terrorist organization, and not just to financiers and bomb makers?

What if an organization that killed also owned a hospital or a school and the law made it a crime to contribute to the hospital or the school? What if the Supreme Court ruled that the law is so broad that it covers backslapping, advocacy and free speech? What if the court ruled that the law makes it a crime to encourage any terrorist organization to do anything — fix teeth, educate children, save lives or kill people? What if the law makes it a crime to talk to any person known to be a terrorist? What if the law is so broad that it punishes ideas and the free expression of those ideas, even if no one is harmed thereby?

What if FBI agents pretended to be members of these terrorist organizations and set out to find people in America who were willing to join? What if the people they found really did want to join a real terrorist organization, but the organizations were located in the Middle East? What if the FBI offered plane tickets and cash to the people they found who said they were interested in joining these groups?

What if FBI agents actually encouraged these people to fly to the Middle East and take up arms in a violent civil war? What if the FBI arrested the people it found and encouraged just as they were about to leave the U.S. and then charged them with providing material assistance to terrorist organizations? What if the president boasted that in his mind these duped dopes were really terrorists and their arrests kept us all safer? What if no material assistance had in fact ever been supplied by those dopes to any terrorist organization?

What if the very members of Congress who voted for this law that prohibits providing material assistance to terrorists by deed or word went and visited people in the Middle East who were fighting a violent civil war? What if these members of Congress concluded that the warriors they visited were good because their adversaries were evil? What if, during a visit, one senator was actually photographed with two al-Qaida-affiliated leaders? What if that was confirmed on national television by the Bush administration ambassador to the United Nations? What if that senator was furious at the former ambassador and insisted that he had not met with al-Qaida? What if that senator encouraged whoever he met with to wage a war of terror on the government of the country they were trying to control? What if that senator insisted that the warriors with whom he met were good warriors because the government they were fighting was evil?

What if the government prosecuted the dopes whom the FBI duped just because it wanted to boast that it caught them? What if the FBI agents who tricked and trapped these dopes encouraged them to join terrorist groups? What if the FBI agents who tricked and trapped these dopes encouraged them to provide material assistance to terrorist-affiliated organizations in the Middle East? What if the senator that the former ambassador exposed offered to get the U.S. government to provide material assistance to terrorist-affiliated organizations? What if he did the same in Libya a few years ago and that brought anarchy to our former ally? What if our own ambassador to Libya was killed by a terrorist group because there was no effective government there to protect him?

What if it is a crime to backslap terror fighters and to encourage their terrorist-affiliated organizations to fight, except if the backslapper is an FBI agent or a senator? What if these terror-fought wars are simply not in the best interests of the American people? What if the backslappers love war because it makes the government stronger? What if the backslappers love war because it is easier to raise taxes, regulate behavior and acquire power for the government when wars are being fought? What if the backslappers are worried that the military might atrophy if it goes a long time without fighting?

What if offensive wars are illegal and morally wrong? What if killing is evil when not done in self-defense? What if those who kill not in self-defense are prosecuted and punished, except when they do so in large numbers and to the sounds of trumpets blaring? What do we do about a government that breaks the laws we have hired it to enforce?


Be the first to read Judge Andrew Napolitano's columns and other Voice of Sanity articles by signing up today and having them delivered directly into your inbox each morning.

Additional articles by Judge Andrew Napolitano

Respond to Writer

Comment Policy: We encourage an open discussion with a wide range of viewpoints. Make your case passionately, but please keep your comments civil and to the point (maximum of 1500 characters). Obscene, profane, abusive, or off-topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked.

If your comment does not appear, it is likely because it violates the above policy or contains links or language typical of spam. We reserve the right to remove comments at our discretion. Thanks for your participation.

6 Responses to “What if Laws Applied to Everyone?”

  1. James the Wanderer says:

    Ballot box, jury box, cartridge box – still the same answer, which is most useful changes from time to time.

  2. Ron the poor laborer says:

    Reading your rhetorical questions brings one answer to mind, loud and clear. Government, especially the present criminal one put there by an inept, dumbed down electorate, is the biggest terrorist. And definitely the most dangerous of them all.

    • One way says:

      The corruption of Human Government from protector / facilitator to dominating dictatorship shows why the God of the Bible, although He loves the universal electorate, John 3:16, will NEVER trust them, and why God expelled them at the beginning, from the Garden of Eden – eternally [Genesis3].

      The expulsion, [Of us from His presence - in whose likeness we were made], defines the REAL "death" of which He warned Adam and Eve.
      The physical death which we all must experience, is a mere picture of that far greater death of which He warned.
      Social death is the biggest death!
      It is a cosmic black hole annihilating the decent harmonious rules by which society must operate! [These God given rules for His human creation are not optional]

      The only human exceptions from the continued expulsion from the Creator are those people who repent and choose the Biblical Christ. Christ who offered to deliver us from the hell caused by Adam's / our rejection of God.

      The Bible shows that mankind, unprotected by Christ, will without exception, eternally stew in its own sinful social juices.

      Ask yourself what can man change? – will a correct vote make any real difference? Look at what is happening today and in the past. What factors are going to arrest the social decline.
      Science cannot solve our social problems but it can be used to bind us and remove freedoms.

      Regardless of the love of God, the universal electorate comprising all of Adam's descendants is too divisive, coercive, self centered, sinful and corrupt to exist cooperatively in God's peaceful kingdom.

      The consequences were seen by Adam [and all of us], after Adam foolishly let the deceiving Trojan Horse serpent into the Garden of Eden. Adam's flesh became the Trojan Horse for Satan to enter God's realm. God stopped the rot immediately by expelling Adam and Eve permanently.
      God will NEVER permit that to happen again even if we plead as we die. We will return to God's presence only if we submit to being washed from sin by Christ.

      To use nuclear terminology, Godlessness and lawlessness has gone "critical". It is no longer naturally restrained.
      Society has by rejecting the God of the Bible refined itself to "weapons grade" evil.
      Human behavior is chain reacting into universal social chaos.
      Human behavior like nuclear radiation is contaminating youthful society with irreversible, and self destructive evils.
      Because of inherent sin, human procreation solves nothing and exacerbates everything.

      Everything brings forth after its own kind.
      Godlessness multiplies godlessness.
      God is also refining, He is refining His people as pure gold into His own kind, to match His image and likeness.
      To become God's kind as we must, we must accept Christ.
      God's kingdom is attractive only to redeemed beatitude lovers – see Mat 5:1-16.

      Godlessness has no genuine social answers except repression thereby increasing the randomness that supposedly built the universe.

      Only Christ can save us from ourselves, using paradoxically, the physical death of our corrupt flesh as a first stage of His process of salvation.
      He saves the seeker into his kingdom while the remainder prefer and choose the progressive destruction of their existing social DNA by wantonly and lawlessly radiating sin thereby corrupting the less sinful.

  3. Aleae T Pennette says:

    Thanks Judge. I’m working on teaching our future generations to “outwit the devil”. Your articles are inspirational to my mission.

  4. Alice says:

    BRAVO!!! What if it were all true? It would be a terrible world to live in!
    Judge, part of the problem is that governments can drum up fervor for these things by making up a threat (or magnifying one that actually exists).
    What if all the people who believe themselves true Christians woke up and realized that we have a volunteer army. Refuse to play the game of world domination wrapped up in that old Patriotism shtick. Not that it is wrong to LOVE your country…but playing stomp the indigenous people for your country IS WRONG.
    What if the army became so thin because people followed the Prince of Peace and went to jail or the guillotine rather than kill someone who wasn't attacking then. What if countries or religions who seemed to hate other people wouldn't actually carry it to war unless they were sick to death of having their country overtly OR covertly messed with for a L-O-N-G time.
    Just askin'.

Leave a Reply

To Receive Free Daily
Articles Via E-mail
Click Here

Featured Columnists

The Problem:
A Government-Created Depression
The Solution: Set the Entrepreneur Free to Create Wealth!

Click here to learn about Robert Ringer's landmark new book, The Entrepreneur:
The Way Back for the U.S. Economy
, that is shocking the establishment.

Liberty Education
Interview Series

Robert Ringer interviews top political, economic, and social leaders on today's most vital and controversial issues.

Dr. Benjamin Carson Interview

Featured Interview:
Dr. Benjamin Carson

Audio file loading...

More Interviews